Veröffentlicht
The Permission to Abandon a Book
Most of us learned to finish what we start, even books we dislike. Here is where that rule came from, how Nancy Pearl's Rule of 50 changes it, and when stopping is simply the right call.
The book you keep meaning to finish
There's probably a book on your nightstand with a bookmark that hasn't moved in a month. Knowing when to stop reading a book is a skill almost nobody teaches. Consider this a small permission slip: you're allowed to put it down.
Where the rule to finish comes from
"Finish what you start" is a lesson learned young, usually somewhere that had nothing to do with pleasure. Nancy Pearl, the librarian and author of Book Lust, was raised on that maxim and applied it to everything, reading included. As a young reader she pushed through books she disliked, Thackeray's Vanity Fair among them. Only later, working as a librarian surrounded by books she wanted to read, did she start to question the habit.
Jeffrey Davies tells a similar story in an essay for Book Riot. In fifth grade he kept a nightly reading log and forced himself through a Hardy Boys book he did not want to read, because he thought it was what boys were supposed to read and because finishing it earned his teacher's praise. He now regrets the time. He also says he once spent as long as six months on a single book because he refused to give up on it.
Both stories point the same way. Finishing is a school habit, rewarded with logs and praise. It isn't a reading habit, and it doesn't have to follow you into your free time.
A rule that fits on an index card
Pearl's answer is the Rule of 50. She has said it came to her on the spur of the moment, when a listener of her weekly KUOW call-in show in Seattle asked how many pages to read before quitting a book. Her advice: give a book 50 pages. At the bottom of page 50, ask whether you are enjoying it. If you are, keep going. If not, "put it down and look for another."
She later added an addendum for readers aged 51 and older. Subtract your age from 100, and the result is the number of pages you should read before you can "guiltlessly give up on a book." The number shrinks every year. Pearl, who said the original rule "worked exceedingly well until I entered my own 50s," closes with a joke: at 100, you are authorized to judge a book by its cover.
It's a rule of thumb, not a verdict, and it was written for leisure reading. It works best as a checkpoint: a moment you chose in advance to ask yourself one honest question. Fifty pages is long enough to hear a writer's voice, and short enough that you haven't lost much.
The cost of the pages you already read
The usual objection is that you've already put hours into the book. Those hours are gone whether you finish or not. What's left is the question of the hours ahead.
Davies makes the opportunity-cost argument plainly: "life is really too short to continue a book you are not enjoying," and the time spent on a book you dislike is time you could have spent on one you would enjoy more. It's an opinion essay with no studies behind it, so take it as a view, not a finding. Most readers will recognize it from their own shelves.
Then there is money. Davies admits he once paid $35 for a hardcover that turned out to be a poor read. His suggestions are practical: borrow from the library first, buy the books you are confident you will want to keep, and if you do end up with one you dislike, gift it, pass it to a friend or donate it. His line is that books "never go to waste." Finishing the book won't get the money back.
For the other end of the day, our piece on reading before bed versus scrolling looks at what the research does and doesn't say.
Stopping is not always final
Putting a book down is not the same as rejecting it. Pearl notes that she has returned to books she rejected and found them transformed: "The book obviously hadn't changed - but I had."
That changes what abandoning means. You aren't judging the book. You're saying this book and this stretch of your life don't fit right now. Some books land better at thirty than at twenty, or in a quiet month than a crowded one.
And if what keeps you turning pages is only the question of how it ends, Pearl has a shortcut for that too: turn to the last page, or the one before it, and find out. She jokes that library staff cannot tell whether you read every page.
Keep a record of what you set down
One small habit makes the next decision easier: write down, in a line or two, why you stopped. "Too slow in the middle." "Loved the sentences, lost the plot." "Not the right month." Over time those notes show you what you actually like, which is more useful than a count of finished books.
Keep them wherever suits you. Our case for a private reading journal with no account describes one low-effort way, and a plain notes file does the job. In a reading app like Margina, the unfinished chapter or PDF simply stays where you left it, with your place saved, until you decide what to do with it.
What the permission is for
Permission isn't an instruction to quit early. It's the freedom to ask, at a checkpoint you chose, whether this book deserves the next hour, and to accept your own answer. Some earn the hour on page 51. Some don't, and they aren't lost. They'll be on the shelf next year.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many pages should I read before I stop a book?
Nancy Pearl suggests 50 pages, then asking whether you are enjoying it. Readers aged 51 and older subtract their age from 100 to get their page count. Treat it as a starting point, not a law.
Is it okay to come back to a book I put down?
Yes. Pearl notes that a book she rejected had not changed, but she had. Setting a book aside is not the same as deciding against it for good.
What about books I paid for?
The money is spent whether you finish or not. Davies suggests borrowing from the library first, and gifting or donating the books you drop.
Does this apply to assigned or work reading?
Not neatly. Pearl's rule is aimed at leisure reading. When a text is required, the question changes from whether to continue to how to read it efficiently.