MarginaGet Margina
Artikel

Veröffentlicht

Does Listening Count as Reading?

Four in ten Americans say listening to an audiobook is not reading. The research says the question is less about legitimacy and more about attention, review and purpose.

For most adults, listening to a book is reading in every way that matters to understanding. The real differences are about attention, review and purpose, not about whether the experience is legitimate.

Plenty of people disagree. An NPR-Ipsos poll taken earlier in 2025 found that 40% of American adults agreed that "listening to audiobooks is not a form of reading". Ipsos's public polling lead called it not a majority but "a significant number." Agreement ran higher among people over 65, men, and people without a four-year degree. The question has a feeling behind it. That feeling deserves a hearing before the evidence gets one.

The thought

Reading, at bottom, is taking in language that someone else arranged and making sense of it. The eyes are one route in. The ears are another, and the older one. Nadine Gaab, a cognitive neuroscientist at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, puts it plainly in the Harvard Gazette: "We all start as listeners."

That doesn't make the two formats identical. It makes "which one is real?" the wrong first question. A better one is what you need from the text, and which format gives it to you.

The longer version

What the comprehension research found

The study most often cited comes from Beth Rogowsky, a professor at Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania, and her colleagues, published in 2016. Adults either read sections of Laura Hillenbrand's nonfiction book Unbroken on an e-reader, listened to them, or did both at once. A comprehension quiz afterward showed no significant difference between the groups. Rogowsky has said she began as a fan of audiobooks who "always viewed them as cheating," and the result surprised her.

The limits matter. Participants were adults who already knew how to read. The comparison used an e-reader, not a printed book, and the coverage we found does not report the sample size. Rogowsky's later work with school-aged children went the other way: students who described themselves as auditory learners scored worse on comprehension across the board. Her reading of that result is that when you are learning to read, you need the experience of reading.

So the fair summary is narrow. For proficient adult readers, in that setup, the format did not change how much they took away.

What the brain is doing

Gaab describes reading and listening as drawing on deeply connected language networks, so the brain works in similar ways whether you read print or hear an audiobook. One difference she names is the region that handles printed letters, which she calls the "letter box." It is less engaged while you listen, though some listeners picture the words and bring it into play anyway.

She also points out that the learning-styles theory has been debunked: it is not the case that someone learns better by listening or by reading. Preference is real. It just doesn't predict outcomes the way people assume. The Gazette piece rests mostly on expert testimony rather than on cited studies, so take this as the view of the researchers quoted, not as a finished experiment.

Where the formats really differ

Print makes it easy to go back. You can glance up the page, highlight, write in the margin, and feel where a passage sits in the whole book. Audio gives you a voice, pacing and tone, and it lets you do something else with your hands. The same freedom makes it easier to drift.

That difference shows up when the goal is learning. A 2010 study coauthored by David Daniel, a psychologist at James Madison University, had students hear a lesson as a podcast or read it on paper. The listeners scored an average of 28% lower on the quiz. Most of the students had wanted the podcast at first, and most switched to reading before the quiz, saying they knew they had not learned as much. Daniel Willingham, a cognitive scientist who has written about reading, draws the practical line: for pleasure reading, he sees "enormous overlap" between audio and print comprehension, but if you are trying to learn while doing two things at once, you will not learn as well.

Those two findings don't contradict each other. One tested a story, the other a lesson to be recalled. Material you must retain and check rewards a format that lets you stop and look again.

Why the idea of purity persists

Alessandra Seiter, a librarian at the Harvard Kennedy School, says in the Gazette piece that there is no purity about reading words on a page. People have always read aloud to one another, and most readers' first books arrived by voice. The sense that listening is a lesser act seems to come from effort. Reading with your eyes feels like work, and audiobooks feel like a way around it. For some listeners, a librarian told the Gazette, audio was simply "their gateway to reading."

A useful corollary

Choose by purpose. If you want the story, the argument or the company of a voice on a long walk, listening is reading. If you need to quote a passage, check a figure or mark something for later, your eyes and a page you can search will serve you better. Plenty of people do both with the same book, and nothing in the research says that's a mistake. If you want to read about how screens change things, we covered reading on paper versus a screen separately.

The same split applies to documents you send yourself. A long PDF or a chapter can be heard when you cannot look at it, and read when you can; we wrote about how read-aloud works on your phone if you want the mechanics. Margina keeps your place either way, and it has no account to create.