公開
Cheap Ebook Sales and What You Actually Own
A sale lowers the price of an ebook, not the terms attached to it. Here is what a store sells you, what happened in 2009, and how to spot a file you can keep.
A lower price is not a different deal
A discount changes what you pay. It does not change what you are buying. When a bestseller drops to $2.99 this week, the terms that come with it are the same ones that came with it at $14.99.
Those terms are worth reading once, calmly, before the holiday sales begin. Here is what a store usually sells you, one well-documented case of a purchase being taken back, what DRM restricts day to day, and how to tell a file you hold from a right you rent.
What a licence can take back
When you press "buy" on an ebook, the product is usually a licence to read the book through the store's system. Amazon's Kindle terms, as quoted on Wikipedia's Kindle page, grant "the non-exclusive right to keep a permanent copy of the applicable Digital Content." That is a right to keep something. It is not title to a file you can do as you like with.
The difference is invisible while everything works. Wikipedia's ebook article lists the ways it can stop working: DRM, a copyright dispute, a provider's business failure, an expired credit card. When a company changes course or goes under, the same article on digital rights management notes, its earlier services may become unavailable. MSN Music, the Yahoo! Music Store and Adobe Content Server 3 are its examples.
There's a quieter question too, one we covered in what happens to your ebooks when you die: a licence tied to an account does not obviously pass to anyone else.
The 2009 deletion
The clearest example is old, and it still teaches. On July 17, 2009, Amazon removed Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four from sale, refunded the buyers and deleted the copies from their Kindles. The seller of those editions had lacked the rights; the books were in the public domain in Canada, Australia and elsewhere, though not in the United States (see when a book enters the public domain for how that varies).
Jeff Bezos apologized on the Kindle forum on July 23. A lawsuit followed on July 30 and settled on September 25, 2009: Amazon paid $150,000, split between the two plaintiffs, and agreed not to delete or modify purchased works on U.S. devices except in listed circumstances, according to the Kindle page.
Nobody lost money, since the price was refunded. What readers lost was the book they had already started, and for at least one of them, the notes written in it. The refund settled the sale. It did nothing for the reading.
What DRM restricts in practice
Digital rights management is the technical side of the licence. Four ebook schemes are in common use, from Adobe, Amazon, Apple and the Marlin Trust Management Organization. Adobe's applies to EPUBs and PDFs. Amazon's descends from the Mobipocket encryption. Apple's FairPlay opens only in Apple's own Books app.
The restrictions it can place on a book are mundane: copying, printing, forwarding, making backup copies. You notice them as small frictions. A purchase that won't open in the reader you prefer. A library you cannot copy to a drive, as we found when looking at why you can't back up a Kindle library to iCloud. A book that lives only where the store lets it live.
We won't walk through ways around any of this. The point here is simpler: know what the restrictions are before you pay, because afterward you can only accept them.
A sale price says nothing about ownership
Product pages tell you more than the price does, if you look. Check which format is listed. Check whether the page says "DRM-free", and whether it names the app that will open the book. A store that sells its books only through its own app, as Wikipedia notes of Amazon, Google, Barnes & Noble, Kobo and Apple, has tied the book to that app by design.
The line you will rarely see says what happens if the store closes. For a little more on what you trade away by reading only inside a store's app, see Google Play Books vs. a dedicated EPUB reader.
Libraries live with the same arrangement. They typically receive a limited licence and do not own the electronic text. If an institution with a collections budget cannot own a licensed ebook, a $2.99 sale on a personal account should not be expected to.
Files you hold yourself
The alternative is unglamorous: an ordinary file. An EPUB or a PDF with no DRM is something you can keep in a folder, copy to a backup drive and open in any reader that supports the format. EPUB reflows to fit the screen; PDF is generally tied to a fixed page layout, so the choice affects how comfortable it is to read on a phone.
Some publishers sell this way on purpose. Tor Books was the first major publisher to omit DRM, in 2012, and O'Reilly, Carina Press and Baen Books had dropped it earlier. The direction has not been one-way: in February 2022 Comixology ended DRM-free downloads for new purchases, though earlier purchases stayed downloadable.
If you hold files like these, a reader that opens them locally is enough. Margina is built that way: it reads the PDFs and EPUBs you already have, keeps them on your device, and has no account or server in between. It is available on the App Store and Google Play.
What to take from the sale
A sale is a fair reason to buy a book. It is a poor reason to stop asking what you are buying. Read the format, look for the DRM-free label, and prefer the version you could still open in ten years without the store's help. Where the only option is a locked copy, treat it as a rental that happens to be cheap, and enjoy it as one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I own an ebook I buy on sale?
Usually you own a licence to read it, not the book as an object. The discount does not change that; the store's terms and any DRM do. Amazon's Kindle terms, for example, grant a non-exclusive right to keep a permanent copy of the content, which is a right and not title to a file you control.
Can a store remove a book I already bought?
It has happened. In July 2009 Amazon deleted copies of two Orwell titles from Kindles after refunding buyers, because the seller lacked the rights. Amazon later settled a lawsuit and agreed not to do this on U.S. devices except in listed circumstances.
What is a DRM-free ebook?
It is an ebook sold without encryption tied to one store's app or account. You can keep it as an ordinary EPUB or PDF file, back it up and open it in any reader that supports the format. Tor Books was the first major publisher to drop DRM, in 2012.